Homicide by Vehicle While DUI in PA - Causation

Homicide by Vehicle While Driving Under the Influence (DUI) is a serious charge in Pennsylvania. The offense carries with it significant legal consequences. Making sure that you have an experienced Pennsylvania DUI attorney by your side is of utmost importance. You don’t want to face the risk of a mandatory minimum sentence alone.

Pennsylvania law under 75 Pa.C.S. Section 3735 holds that a person is guilty of Homicide by Vehicle While DUI if they unintentionally cause the death of another person while operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or controlled substances. In cases where more than one person has lost their life, the district attorney can file separate counts of Homicide While Under the Influence for each fatality.

In Pennsylvania DUI cases, a conviction for Homicide by Vehicle While DUI, as a second-degree felony, carries a minimum prison term of three years. However, the judge has the right to impose a sentence of up to ten years in prison. The judge may also impose a fine of up to $25,000 for each count of this offense.

The Significance of Causation

In the realm of Homicide by Vehicle While DUI cases, causation emerges as the linchpin of the prosecution’s argument. It’s not merely a matter of proving impairment; it’s about proving that this impairment unequivocally led to a tragic accident resulting in loss of life. This legal principle hinges on establishing a clear and direct connection between the defendant’s actions and the fatal outcome.

Causation, in legal terms, delves into the intricate web of events and circumstances that ended up in the accident. It requires a meticulous examination of the sequence of facts leading up to the incident. This includes scrutinizing factors like blood alcohol concentration, vehicular speed, weather conditions, and any potential contributing factors from the deceased party.

Challenges in Establishing Causation

Proving causation beyond a reasonable doubt is no small feat. It demands a thorough and comprehensive analysis of all available evidence. This may involve accident reconstruction specialists, toxicology experts, and eyewitness testimonies. Additionally, it necessitates a deep understanding of the nuances of DUI laws and their application in Pennsylvania.

Potential Defenses

Given the complexity of causation, there are several potential avenues for your defense attorney to explore. This may involve challenging the reliability of certain pieces of evidence, questioning the accuracy of accident reconstruction, or presenting alternative explanations for the sequence of events. In some cases, it may also involve showing that factors not related to the accused’s impairment played a significant role in the accident.

Expert Testimonies

Expert witnesses often play a crucial role in establishing or disputing causation. Their specialized knowledge can shed light on critical aspects such as the impact of intoxication on driving abilities, the physics of the accident, or even the role of external factors like road conditions.

Defending Against a Homicide by Vehicle While DUI Charge

A seasoned defense attorney understands the weight that causation holds in a Homicide by Vehicle While DUI case. They will leave no stone unturned in scrutinizing the prosecution’s case, looking for any weaknesses or gaps in their argument regarding causation. This could involve consulting their own experts, conducting exhaustive investigations, and crafting a compelling narrative that challenges the prosecution’s version of events.

Why Choose Shuttleworth Law P.C.?

Homicide by Vehicle While DUI charges demand the highest level of legal expertise and strategic defense. Proactive and timely legal intervention can make a significant difference. If you or a loved one is facing such charges, don’t face it alone. Contact an experienced Philadelphia Homicide by Vehicle While DUI lawyer at Shuttleworth Law P.C. for a detailed discussion about your case and potential defense strategies.

Call 888-529-3486 (avail. 24/7) or message us privately online to schedule your Free Case Evaluation as soon as possible.

Darren Isomoto 1 week ago

Mr. Shuttleworth is extremely experienced, and his calm, approachable demeanor immediately puts clients at ease. He is very communicative and thorough, and he explains everything clearly, which made the entire process much easier to understand.

...

Michael M 1 month ago

Brad was awesome! Very communicative. Expert counsel

Damon Galdo 2 months ago

Very professional. Brad was very kind and went out of his way to help out with matters not specific to my case. 5 stars across the board!

nicholas 2 months ago

It was awesome working with Brad, he was very trustworthy, communication was excellent and very easy person to work with. I would 1000% recommend to anyone. Thanks Brad and his team for their help.

Matt Phelps 2 months ago

Brad was always available to answer questions and always ensured they were answered in their entirety. I had spoken to other attorneys who just wanted to throw a large $$$ retainer without explaining exactly what they could deliver. Brad looked over the issue I brought to him, assessed the situation, and clearly explained what he could deliver. Brad ensured every aspect of the case was reviewed to ensure the best outcome was achieved. When meeting with Brad, he ensured his focus was on you and made you feel like his only client was you. Hands down, I highly recommend Brad!

Dave 2 months ago

Brad and his firm helped me quickly, fast response! Making it a smooth process. Took the time with me to go over details, even on a Sunday. I could tell he was on the phone at home, hearing his family in the background. left me with a good feeling i made right choice! can't recommend enough!

Melissa Rivera 3 months ago

Brad is very professional and honest, his staff is incredibly knowledgeable and helpful as well. From the moment we spoke I knew he was the lawyer to handle our case.

Melissa Montes 3 months ago

Brad was my fiancé’s attorney, he was truly exceptional from start to finish. He was incredibly attentive, knowledgeable, and well-mannered throughout the entire process. He consistently kept us informed, was reliable every step of the way, and ultimately got our case dismissed. His professionalism and dedication made a stressful situation so much easier. I highly recommend him to anyone in need of a defense attorney—his service is outstanding and absolutely deserves five stars. Thank you Brad!! Vinny and Melissa

Nicholas Caputo 3 months ago

I spoke with several attorneys before I decided on Brad. It was clear to me based on these discussions, that Brad was the one to go with - he is extremely knowledgeable and skilled in the field of copyright law. The information he provided was more consistent with my own research than others, he was able to share new information with me that I was able to independently confirm as accurate, and his proposed action plan and projected goal for settlement was far better than the competition. Brad answered literally all of my questions to my satisfaction and made himself available and accessible for regular contact via multiple methods. Brad is also very familiar with the attorneys in this space on the opposing side and has much experience in dealing with them. In the end, the whole process took about 6-7 weeks, and we settled for an amount that was even better than our initial projected goal. I am very pleased and impressed with the outcome and Brad's overall performance. I would certainly engage him again in the future and would recommend him to anyone attempting to effectively and efficiently resolve a copyright case. Five Stars.