Shuttleworth Law P.C.

Shuttleworth Law P.C.

Call 888-529-3486
For a Free Case Evaluation

  • Home
  • Practice Areas
    • Criminal Defense
      • Assault & Domestic Violence
      • Burglary, Robbery & Theft
      • Computer Crimes
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Criminal Investigations
      • Drug Crimes
      • DUI Defense
      • Expungements
      • Gun Crimes Defense
      • Homicide, Manslaughter, & Murder
      • Sex Crimes
      • Violent Crimes Defense
      • White-collar Crimes
    • Personal Injury
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Car Accidents
      • Construction Accident
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Premises Liability
      • Wrongful Death
    • Protection From Abuse (PFA)
      • PFA Defense
      • PFAs for Victims
    • Strike 3 Holdings Defense
  • About Us
    • Brad V. Shuttleworth
    • Recent Case Results
    • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Shuttleworth Law P.C. Client Portal
    • FAQs
  • Contact Us Now

Sucker Punch Causing Serious Bodily Injury Enough for Aggravated Assault?

Published on Dec 17, 2007

A single sucker punch causing the victim to sustain serious bodily injury is enough for a case to go to trial on an aggravated assault charge. In Commonwealth v. Patrick, 933 A.2d 1043 (Pa. Super. 2007), an en banc Pennsylvania Superior Court issued an opinion, written by Judge Gantman, holding that where a defendant delivers a single sucker punch to the side of the victim’s face with enough force to knock the victim off his feet, and where he hit the sidewalk head first and spent two days in a coma due to severe brain trauma, there is enough evidence for the case to go to trial because there exists evidence of the defendant’s recklessness under circumstances manifesting the extreme indifference to the value of human life.

Simply put, a sucker punch with absolutely no warning that puts the victim in a coma will be enough evidence to prosecute a defendant for aggravated assault. Speak with a Philadelphia assault lawyer if you are facing chrages or have questions.

Dissenting Opinion by Todd, J:

Here is the dissenting opinion in this case:

“[F]or the degree of recklessness contained in the aggravated assault statute to occur, the offensive act must be performed under circumstances which almost assure that injury or death will ensue. The recklessness must, therefore, be such that life threatening injury is essentially certain to occur. This state of mind is, accordingly, equivalent to that which seeks to cause injury. Examples of such behavior make the distinction clear. In Commonwealth v. Daniels, 467 Pa. 35, 354 A.2d 538 (1976), appellant had fired a gun into a crowd; in Commonwealth v. Laing, 310 Pa.Super. 105, 456 A.2d 204 (1983), appellant drove his car into a crowd, after having aimed it at an individual; in [Commonwealth v.] Scofield, [360 Pa.Super. 552, 521 A.2d 40 (1987),] the appellant drove at a pedestrian. See also, Commonwealth v. Hlatky, 426 Pa.Super. 66, 626 A.2d 575 (1993); Commonwealth v. Rohach, 344 Pa.Super. 229, 496 A.2d 768 (1985). In each of these instances, the defendant could reasonably anticipate that serious bodily injury or death would be the likely and logical consequence of his actions. In each case, the consequence was ignored.”
You can also learn about how the Commonwealth requires prove of causation in aggravated assault with a vehicle while intoxicated here.

Laws Relevant to This Case

18 Pa.C.S.A. § 2702(a)(1)

Aggravated assault.
(a) Offense defined.–A person is guilty of aggravated assault if he:
(1) attempts to cause serious bodily injury to another, or causes such injury intentionally, knowingly or recklessly under circumstances manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life.

Were You Charged with a Crime in Pennsylvania or New Jersey?

If so, I can help, and I’m not afraid of taking on tough cases, either. Put an innovative and experienced criminal defense lawyer on your side by contacting me at Shuttleworth Law P.C. for a Free Case Evaluation. Call 888-529-3486 or message me here directly to request yours today.

Criminal Defense

Categories

  • Civil Rights (3)
  • Criminal Defense (180)
    • Appeals (1)
    • Arrests (4)
    • Assault (2)
    • Burglary (2)
    • Child Abuse (1)
    • Computer Crimes (7)
    • Conspiracy (2)
    • Contempt (3)
    • Corruption (2)
    • Criminal Law Courts (21)
    • Domestic Violence (4)
    • Drug Charges (4)
    • DUI (5)
    • Evidence (4)
    • Expungements & Pardons (3)
    • Felonies (7)
    • Forgery (3)
    • Gun Charges (18)
    • Homicide (7)
    • Insurance Fraud (3)
    • Manslaughter (4)
    • Misdemeanors (2)
    • Murder (1)
    • Pleas (1)
    • Police Conduct (9)
    • Prisons & Jails (11)
    • Probation and Parole (4)
    • Property Crime (1)
    • Rape (1)
    • Robbery (4)
    • Search & Seizure (31)
    • Sentencing (18)
    • Sex Crimes (6)
    • Traffic Stops (5)
    • Violent Crime (4)
    • Warrants (4)
    • Weapons (5)
    • White-Collar Crimes (2)
    • Wire Fraud (1)
  • Federal Indictments (1)
  • General Legal News (17)
  • Law Firm News (8)
  • Legislation (6)
  • Personal Injury (5)
    • Car Accidents (1)
    • Fault (1)
    • Pedestrian Accidents (1)
    • Statute of Limitations (1)
    • Wrongful Death (1)
  • Protection From Abuse (PFA) (7)
    • PFA Defense (5)
  • Restraining Order (1)
  • Statutes of LImitation (1)
  • Strike 3 Holdings (8)
  • Uncategorized (2)

Placeholder. Do not Delete.

google
Wentao Lu 2 weeks ago
Very satisfied by the service provided by Shuttleworth! Before the commitment, Mr. Brad Shuttleworth had a detailed zoom meeting free of charge on my case which made is super easy for me to trust him. He gave me thorough instructions how to prepare the case on my end and settled my case very quickly, much better than what I expected. I will definitely ask him for help in the future if I need his legal service again and strongly recommend to anyone I know.
...
google
Mike Seansy 2 weeks ago
I highly recommend Shuttleworth Law. Brad was incredibly professional and kept me informed every step of the way. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled smoothly. I truly appreciate his dedication and expertise. You won’t be disappointed!
...
google
Josh “Jay” Delgado 3 weeks ago
I couldn’t be more grateful for the exceptional legal support I receive, Brad is always professional, responsive, and truly has my companies best interests at heart every step of the way. His knowledge, attention to detail, and dedication makes every stressful situation so much easier to manage. Communication is always clear and timely, and I feel confident knowing we have someone so capable in my companies corner. I highly recommend his services to anyone in need of a skilled and trustworthy attorney.
...
google
H Wai 1 month ago
Being caught up in a lawsuit was a nightmare, I was glad that I found Brad during this disturbing time. I had talked to a few attorneys about my case, Brad was the one who could give me trustworthy and honest advice. He is patience, experienced and professional. I would recommend him to anyone who needs an honest attorney.
...
google
Jamie Wiebrand 2 months ago
Brad helped me through a difficult situation. I'm not sure where we would have been without him.
...
google
Greg Hake 2 months ago
I was very pleased with Brad, he went out of his way to settle for me.
...
google
Julie Brown 2 months ago
If you have question or need help for yourself or a family member Brad is very helpful. He will guide you through each step of the process. He was quick to respond to additional questions. He will ensure you get the best outcome.
...
google
Zach Parnell 3 months ago
I highly recommend working with Brad and his team.
...
google
Marty Kassowitz 3 months ago
I was both impressed and comforted by Brad's very professional handling of an upsetting legal situation. His care and attention were flawless and appreciated.
...

Shuttleworth Law, P.C.
New Jersey Office:
1040 Mantua Pike
Wenonah NJ 08090
856-681-0185

Pennsylvania Office:
By appointment only

Call 888-529-3486
Available 24/7 for emergencies

Business Hours
Monday – Friday
8 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Facebook
Instagram
LinkedIn
TikTok
X (Formerly Twitter)

This website is for informational purposes only. Information presented isn’t legal advice and doesn’t form attorney-client relationships. Past results aren’t indicative of future results as all cases are unique. Laws affect each situation differently.

Copyright © 2005-2025 Brad V. Shuttleworth, Esq., Shuttleworth Law P.C. | Privacy Policy