No matter which legal drama you’ve watched, chances are you’ve run across a scene where a detective lies to a suspect during an interrogation. The suspect eventually confesses to a crime. But just how true is that scenario? Can the police lie to you while investigating?
The answer is yes, but only in certain circumstances. The question of whether New Jersey police can lie to suspects falls under the ruling in a Supreme Court case, Frazier v. Cupp, 394 U.S. 731 (1969). This case ruled that police are allowed to use deception when getting a confession as long as they don’t commit entrapment.
Entrapment is when police induce or encourage the commission of a crime to obtain evidence of that crime in violation of NJ Rev Stat § 2C:2-12 (2023). Police deception can lead to wrongful convictions, erode public trust in law enforcement, and disproportionately affect vulnerable populations. In numerous cases, false confessions have led to miscarriages of justice because of deceptive police practices. In fact, people have spent decades in prison for crimes they did not commit.
DO NOT go in for questioning if the police are investigating you for a crime. Politely, but firmly decline. Even if they tell you they “just want to talk” or they “just need to clear some things up.”
Call Shuttleworth Law, P.C. before you speak to law enforcement. Find out how 20 years of hard-fought, hard-won experience can help you decide on the right approach for your situation. Our expertise is backed by the legal resources needed to deliver results.
The Current Legal Landscape in New Jersey
Traditionally, courts across the United States, including those in New Jersey, have allowed police officers to use specific deceptive tactics during interrogations. This practice stems from the belief that such techniques can effectively elicit confessions from guilty parties. However, this approach has also been criticized for potentially leading to false confessions, especially from vulnerable individuals.
As of 2024, New Jersey law does not explicitly prohibit all forms of police deception during interrogations. However, there is a growing movement to reform these practices, particularly when interrogating juveniles and individuals with mental health issues. In 2021, New Jersey took a significant step by passing a law prohibiting law enforcement from using deceptive tactics when interrogating individuals under 18. This legislation, which went into effect in 2022, makes any confession obtained through the use of false information inadmissible in court proceedings against a juvenile. This reform was partly inspired by research showing that young people are particularly susceptible to false confessions when faced with deceptive interrogation tactics. The law aims to protect the rights of minors and ensure that any confessions obtained are genuine and voluntary.
The Gray Area of Adult Interrogations
For adult suspects, the situation remains less clear-cut. While the New Jersey Supreme Court has not issued a blanket ban on police deception during interrogations, it has set some boundaries:
Voluntariness Test: Any confession obtained must be voluntary. If a court determines that police deception rendered a confession involuntary, it can be deemed inadmissible.
Materiality: The deception must not be so egregious that it would induce an innocent person to confess. Courts consider factors such as the nature of the deception, the suspect’s age and mental capacity, and the overall circumstances of the interrogation.
Constitutional Rights: Police cannot lie about a suspect’s constitutional rights. For example, they cannot falsely claim that a suspect doesn’t have the right to remain silent or to have an attorney present during questioning.
Things to Keep In Mind
Given the current legal landscape, if you find yourself under police investigation, always get representation as soon as possible, preferably before giving any statements to the police. Call us immediately.
Know Your Rights
Remember that you have the right to remain silent and the right to have an attorney present during questioning. Police cannot lie about these fundamental rights. If you agree to police questioning or go to the station “just to answer a few questions,” remember that you have the right to immediately request an attorney before answering any questions. An attorney can help protect your rights and advise you on the best course of action.
While police may use some forms of deception, they cannot lie about your constitutional rights or use tactics that would render any confession involuntary. Remain calm and composed during any interaction with law enforcement. Emotional distress can make you more vulnerable to suggestive or deceptive tactics.
The key takeaway for New Jersey residents is that while police deception is not entirely prohibited, there are limits to what law enforcement can do. The best protection against potential abuses is to be aware of your rights and to exercise them judiciously.
Protect Your Rights and Your Freedom! Call Us Today.
If police try to ask you questions, remember that you have the right to remain silent, the right to an attorney, and the right to be treated fairly under the law. Exercise these rights wisely, and call us if you’re unsure how to proceed.
Brad Shuttleworth is an award-winning New Jersey criminal defense lawyer recognized for his results, client relationships, and courtroom experience. If you want to approach your case the right way, call our office for Your Free Case Evaluation at 888-529-3486 or confidentially message us here.
Let us know if you cannot visit our office for Your Free Initial Consultation. Our firm can meet by phone or secure video chat!